[RPC-Spec-V2] Allow chainHead operations to be made from a single connection #3207
Comments
This was referenced Feb 5, 2024
Sounds good to me; I'd previously assumed that subscription IDs were scoped to the connection already, and it's def safer to ensure that they are :)
I don't understand this sentence really? |
|
For this case to happen, the user needs 2 separate connections to the same server. From the user perspective, this is unlikely to happen for our production nodes. For example, connecting 2 times to However, if the user targets a localhost node / development node, or a node with a known IP address this behavior could be reproduced. Indeed the misleading of my issue is |
1 task
github-merge-queue bot
pushed a commit
that referenced
this issue
Apr 2, 2024
… context and limit connections (#3481) This PR ensures that the chainHead RPC class can be called only from within the same connection context. The chainHead methods are now registered as raw methods. - paritytech/jsonrpsee#1297 The concept of raw methods is introduced in jsonrpsee, which is an async method that exposes the connection ID: The raw method doesn't have the concept of a blocking method. Previously blocking methods are now spawning a blocking task to handle their blocking (ie DB) access. We spawn the same number of tasks as before, however we do that explicitly. Another approach would be implementing a RPC middleware that captures and decodes the method parameters: - #3343 However, that approach is prone to errors since the methods are hardcoded by name. Performace is affected by the double deserialization that needs to happen to extract the subscription ID we'd like to limit. Once from the middleware, and once from the methods itself. This PR paves the way to implement the chainHead connection limiter: - #1505 Registering tokens (subscription ID / operation ID) on the `RpcConnections` could be extended to return an error when the maximum number of operations is reached. While at it, have added an integration-test to ensure that chainHead methods can be called from within the same connection context. Before this is merged, a new JsonRPC release should be made to expose the `raw-methods`: - [x] Use jsonrpsee from crates io (blocked by: paritytech/jsonrpsee#1297) Closes: #3207 cc @paritytech/subxt-team --------- Signed-off-by: Alexandru Vasile <[email protected]> Co-authored-by: Niklas Adolfsson <[email protected]>
Ank4n
pushed a commit
that referenced
this issue
Apr 9, 2024
… context and limit connections (#3481) This PR ensures that the chainHead RPC class can be called only from within the same connection context. The chainHead methods are now registered as raw methods. - paritytech/jsonrpsee#1297 The concept of raw methods is introduced in jsonrpsee, which is an async method that exposes the connection ID: The raw method doesn't have the concept of a blocking method. Previously blocking methods are now spawning a blocking task to handle their blocking (ie DB) access. We spawn the same number of tasks as before, however we do that explicitly. Another approach would be implementing a RPC middleware that captures and decodes the method parameters: - #3343 However, that approach is prone to errors since the methods are hardcoded by name. Performace is affected by the double deserialization that needs to happen to extract the subscription ID we'd like to limit. Once from the middleware, and once from the methods itself. This PR paves the way to implement the chainHead connection limiter: - #1505 Registering tokens (subscription ID / operation ID) on the `RpcConnections` could be extended to return an error when the maximum number of operations is reached. While at it, have added an integration-test to ensure that chainHead methods can be called from within the same connection context. Before this is merged, a new JsonRPC release should be made to expose the `raw-methods`: - [x] Use jsonrpsee from crates io (blocked by: paritytech/jsonrpsee#1297) Closes: #3207 cc @paritytech/subxt-team --------- Signed-off-by: Alexandru Vasile <[email protected]> Co-authored-by: Niklas Adolfsson <[email protected]>
dharjeezy
pushed a commit
to dharjeezy/polkadot-sdk
that referenced
this issue
Apr 9, 2024
… context and limit connections (paritytech#3481) This PR ensures that the chainHead RPC class can be called only from within the same connection context. The chainHead methods are now registered as raw methods. - paritytech/jsonrpsee#1297 The concept of raw methods is introduced in jsonrpsee, which is an async method that exposes the connection ID: The raw method doesn't have the concept of a blocking method. Previously blocking methods are now spawning a blocking task to handle their blocking (ie DB) access. We spawn the same number of tasks as before, however we do that explicitly. Another approach would be implementing a RPC middleware that captures and decodes the method parameters: - paritytech#3343 However, that approach is prone to errors since the methods are hardcoded by name. Performace is affected by the double deserialization that needs to happen to extract the subscription ID we'd like to limit. Once from the middleware, and once from the methods itself. This PR paves the way to implement the chainHead connection limiter: - paritytech#1505 Registering tokens (subscription ID / operation ID) on the `RpcConnections` could be extended to return an error when the maximum number of operations is reached. While at it, have added an integration-test to ensure that chainHead methods can be called from within the same connection context. Before this is merged, a new JsonRPC release should be made to expose the `raw-methods`: - [x] Use jsonrpsee from crates io (blocked by: paritytech/jsonrpsee#1297) Closes: paritytech#3207 cc @paritytech/subxt-team --------- Signed-off-by: Alexandru Vasile <[email protected]> Co-authored-by: Niklas Adolfsson <[email protected]>
Sign up for free
to join this conversation on GitHub.
Already have an account?
Sign in to comment
The chainHead-cli tool proves that we can have:
chainHead_folowchainHead_storagewith the subscription ID of the first connection; and produces the result in the first connectionTo restrict this case, ensure that the subscription ID provided by the
chainHead_followis valid within the context of that connection only.Repro case
This issue can be reproduced if the user makes 2 separate connections to the same RPC server.
For the common scenario, the user would establish 2 connections via
rpc-polkadot.io, which would most likely generate 2 connections on different servers.However, if the user knows the IP address of the server (or targets a local-development node for testing) this could be reproduced.
cc @paritytech/subxt-team
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: