Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Fix 7-bit support for teensy4 and teensy3 #665

Draft
wants to merge 2 commits into
base: master
Choose a base branch
from

Conversation

ssilverman
Copy link
Contributor

Fixes #664

@ssilverman
Copy link
Contributor Author

It turns out that without the fix, the transmit properly sends 7-bit data, but receive still sometimes sets the 8th bit high. I need to explore more...

@ssilverman ssilverman marked this pull request as draft November 18, 2022 06:58
@ssilverman
Copy link
Contributor Author

On my journey to understanding this better — It's been a while since I've explored this in depth (for TeensyDMX) — I think I'm re-discovering that the "data" includes everything but the start and stop bits. This means that my proposed solution, setting M7, will really cause a 6-bit data byte if there's parity. If I'm right, then my solution isn't correct. I'm closer...

@ssilverman
Copy link
Contributor Author

ssilverman commented Nov 18, 2022

See: https://forum.pjrc.com/threads/71505-7-bit-support-seems-to-be-missing-on-Teensy-4

That top bit, because it's the last in the stream, turns out to be the value of the parity bit. On to a fix...

@ssilverman
Copy link
Contributor Author

ssilverman commented Nov 18, 2022

Okay, I think I got it. There has to be an appropriate mask depending on the mode.

I tested this with a 7E1 device, both directions.

@ssilverman ssilverman marked this pull request as ready for review November 18, 2022 14:53
@ssilverman ssilverman changed the title Add 7-bit support to teensy4 HardwareSerial Fix 7-bit support in teensy4 HardwareSerial Nov 18, 2022
@ssilverman ssilverman force-pushed the fix-664 branch 2 times, most recently from deb34ce to 5454196 Compare November 18, 2022 15:38
@ssilverman ssilverman changed the title Fix 7-bit support in teensy4 HardwareSerial Fix 7-bit support for teensy4 and teensy3 Nov 18, 2022
@ssilverman
Copy link
Contributor Author

ssilverman commented Nov 18, 2022

I updated the PR to include a commit for fixing teensy3 7-bit support.

Tested with the same 7E1 device.

@ssilverman
Copy link
Contributor Author

Here's my logic for fixing this: All formats other than 7-bit don't set the parity bit when a user reads bytes. It is unexpected for the 7-bit format to set the parity bit. This PR fixes this case. If this is not fixed, then, in my opinion, it should be documented.

@KurtE
Copy link
Contributor

KurtE commented Dec 16, 2022

Quick update: As I mentioned on the forum thread. The other 8 bit and 9 bit also return the parity. But by default the software FIFO queues are 8 bits per element, so the data is lost.

There is a #define commented out in the HardwareSerial.h that enables the FIFO queue to be uint16_t instead and it does return the actual data including the parity bit.

Posted test sketch in the forum thread, but with that bit on, it outputs:


Test format: SERIAL_7E1 Write time us: 170
41(A) 42(B) C3(C) 44(D) C5(E) C6(F) 47(G) 48(H) C9(I) CA(J) 4B(K) CC(L) 4D(M) 4E(N) CF(O) 50(P)  : 7B FC 7D 7E FF 

Test format: SERIAL_7O1 Write time us: 171
C1(A) C2(B) 43(C) C4(D) 45(E) 46(F) C7(G) C8(H) 49(I) 4A(J) CB(K) 4C(L) CD(M) CE(N) 4F(O) D0(P)  : FB 7C FD FE 7F 

Test format: SERIAL_8N1 Write time us: 171
41(A) 42(B) 43(C) 44(D) 45(E) 46(F) 47(G) 48(H) 49(I) 4A(J) 4B(K) 4C(L) 4D(M) 4E(N) 4F(O) 50(P)  : FB FC FD FE FF 

Test format: SERIAL_8E1 Write time us: 188
41(A) 42(B) 143(C) 44(D) 145(E) 146(F) 47(G) 48(H) 149(I) 14A(J) 4B(K) 14C(L) 4D(M) 4E(N) 14F(O) 50(P)  : 1FB FC 1FD 1FE FF 

Test format: SERIAL_8O1 Write time us: 188
141(A) 142(B) 43(C) 144(D) 45(E) 46(F) 147(G) 148(H) 49(I) 4A(J) 14B(K) 4C(L) 14D(M) 14E(N) 4F(O) 150(P)  : FB 1FC FD FE 1FF 

Test format: SERIAL_9N1 Write time us: 188
41(A) 42(B) 43(C) 44(D) 45(E) 46(F) 47(G) 48(H) 49(I) 4A(J) 4B(K) 4C(L) 4D(M) 4E(N) 4F(O) 50(P)  : 1FB 1FC 1FD 1FE 1FF 

Test format: SERIAL_9E1 Write time us: 205
41(A) 42(B) 243(C) 44(D) 245(E) 246(F) 47(G) 48(H) 249(I) 24A(J) 4B(K) 24C(L) 4D(M) 4E(N) 24F(O) 50(P)  : 1FB 3FC 1FD 1FE 3FF 

Test format: SERIAL_9O1 Write time us: 205
241(A) 242(B) 43(C) 244(D) 45(E) 46(F) 247(G) 248(H) 49(I) 4A(J) 24B(K) 4C(L) 24D(M) 24E(N) 4F(O) 250(P)  : 3FB 1FC 3FD 3FE 1FF 

Note in each of the output lines for the different Formats I output A-P and I also now after the : in each line try to output the top values for these formats. As to make sure whole range is returned.
Note: With 9 bit output, you need to use a special write method, as shown in the sketch

@ssilverman ssilverman marked this pull request as draft April 26, 2023 17:47
Don't include the parity bit for returned data.
Don't include the parity bit for returned data.
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
None yet
Projects
None yet
Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

7-bit serial support on Teensy 4 sets top bit
2 participants